Trump Is Tearing Down Election Security Systems. State Officials Are Alarmed



Election Day Disruption and the Response to Threats

Misha Pride, then the mayor of South Portland, Maine, was welcoming voters on Election Day when a sudden surge of police cars, lights flashing, appeared outside the city’s community center. A text from the city manager read, "Possible shooting." Officers immediately secured the area, and although the situation seemed alarming, authorities soon determined that the call was a hoax. It was one of hundreds of threats and cyberattacks targeting the 2024 presidential election, many orchestrated by partisan extremists or foreign actors, including Russia and China. Fortunately, the hoax resulted in only a brief ten-minute delay in voting.

This prompt response was due in part to an extensive information-sharing and analysis network that involved federal, state, and local election officials, along with cybersecurity and law enforcement agencies. This network played a pivotal role in thwarting attacks in Maine and across the country, thanks to careful preparation and swift action. However, a recent investigation by CNN has uncovered troubling actions by the Trump administration and Elon Musk's Department of Government Efficiency, which are dismantling key elements of this network, built over the past eight years. As a result, election offices nationwide are scrambling to fortify their defenses against future threats.

Staff Layoffs and Cuts to Security Infrastructure

In early February, the Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency (CISA), under Musk's leadership, laid off 130 employees, including ten regional security specialists who had been working directly with state and local election officials. Additionally, the Trump administration is pushing plans to strip civil service protections from 80% of the remaining CISA workforce, which could make it easier to fire employees for political reasons. This move is part of a broader effort by Trump’s appointees, such as Attorney General Pam Bondi and Homeland Security chief Kristi Noem, to dismantle critical structures aimed at safeguarding election security.

Noem, in particular, took steps to cancel funding for national information-sharing efforts that helped state and local officials detect and counter cyber threats. Meanwhile, Bondi disbanded an important FBI task force investigating foreign efforts to interfere with U.S. elections and another tasked with investigating threats against election workers. These actions have raised serious concerns among election officials, who fear these cuts will undermine the security of upcoming elections.

Tensions Over Election Security and Disinformation

Trump’s appointees, including Bondi, Noem, and FBI Director Kash Patel, have openly embraced the false narrative of widespread voter fraud, which has fueled efforts to strip down the infrastructure put in place to protect elections. For example, Noem has criticized CISA for straying from its core mission by focusing on foreign disinformation, while Bondi has defended her decision to disband the Foreign Influence Task Force by claiming it was a necessary step to prevent "weaponization" of prosecutorial discretion.

These moves have alarmed state officials, particularly those in bipartisan associations representing secretaries of state. They have raised concerns about how election security measures will function in the future, but so far, they have not received clear answers from the White House.

The Development of Election Security Post-2016

Much of the election security framework now under attack by the Trump administration was developed after the 2016 election. Following reports that Russia and its proxies had interfered in the election through cyberattacks and disinformation campaigns, the Obama administration declared election infrastructure critical in January 2017. This led to the creation of several key agencies and task forces aimed at protecting elections.

In 2018, Trump signed into law the Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency Act, which established CISA as a central body responsible for defending critical infrastructure, including election systems. However, recent criticisms of CISA, particularly over its role in countering disinformation on social media, have led to calls from conservatives to strip down the agency’s powers. This includes a proposal from the Heritage Foundation's "Project 2025," which advocates for a significant reduction in CISA’s role in election security and counter-disinformation efforts.

Ongoing Challenges and the Loss of Critical Resources

In February, CISA's acting director, Bridget Bean, initiated layoffs of 130 employees, many of whom were involved in election security and counter-disinformation efforts. The agency has yet to disclose the outcome of an internal review of these actions, which was completed in early March. Despite legal orders to reinstate the fired employees, some, like Kyle Rahn, remain on administrative leave, highlighting the uncertainty and instability within the agency.

Meanwhile, Noem directed the termination of more than $9 million in contracts with the Center for Internet Security, which provided crucial support to state and local election officials. One of the most important programs affected by these cuts is the Elections Infrastructure Information Sharing and Analysis Center (EI-ISAC), which brought together election officials from across the country to share information on potential threats. Without this resource, election officials are struggling to maintain the level of coordination that helped protect the integrity of elections in 2020.

The Impact on Election Integrity

The loss of these resources is already being felt. Maine Secretary of State Shenna Bellows reported a dramatic increase in cyber threats from 2023 to 2024, with a 158% rise in the number of threats reported by members of the EI-ISAC. The Center for Internet Security also blocked over 138,000 attempted links to malicious domains on Election Day alone in 2024. With the dismantling of key cybersecurity resources, election officials are left vulnerable to escalating threats.



Rahn, once a manager in CISA’s infrastructure security division, expressed disbelief over the loss of the election integrity ISAC, warning that these actions are creating "holes" in election security. Bellows echoed this concern, stating that the collaboration fostered by EI-ISAC was crucial for maintaining the integrity of the election process.

Uncertainty About Future Election Security

As state and local officials struggle to adapt to these cuts, there is growing concern about how elections will be protected in the future. Bondi’s disbanding of the FBI’s Foreign Influence Task Force has left a critical gap in the fight against foreign interference, while the fate of other agencies and task forces remains unclear. With experts warning of increased vulnerabilities in upcoming elections, it is uncertain how much the system will be able to withstand without the protections that were once in place.

Ultimately, the dismantling of key election security components is raising alarm bells across the political spectrum. The question now is whether the U.S. can maintain the integrity of its elections in the face of these challenges.

Scrambling for Solutions Amid Election Security Cuts

In the wake of significant cuts to the Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency (CISA) and other critical agencies, state and local election officials are scrambling to find solutions to ensure election security without federal assistance. Maggie Toulouse Oliver, the Democratic Secretary of State for New Mexico, expressed concern to CNN, saying, “There’s been so much work done… to shore those up and create a national network. Now we’re looking at it being completely dismantled. We feel like we’re having to combat these foreign threats and domestic threats as individual states. Without the assistance of the federal government, how do we make that happen?”



The National Association of Secretaries of State, which is bipartisan, has raised alarms about the cuts, urging Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem to maintain CISA’s core election services. In a letter sent on February 21, the association pointed out that CISA and the Elections Infrastructure Information Sharing and Analysis Center (EI-ISAC) had successfully shielded elections from sophisticated cyber threats by nation-state actors and cybercriminal groups. Meanwhile, U.S. Senators, led by Alex Padilla, also demanded clarification from CISA regarding the termination of vital services. Arizona’s Secretary of State, Adrian Fontes, likened the cuts to "kneecapping the Federal Aviation Administration while [it’s] managing thousands of active flights," stressing how CISA’s support had been crucial in managing threats against Arizona’s election officials.

Fontes noted that while a White House official returned his call, no clear answers were provided. "The administration's utter lack of communication is currently my biggest problem," he said, adding, "If they’re just going to wholly eviscerate these services, that’s highly problematic."

Alternative Support and Ongoing Concerns

On March 7, Noem responded to concerns by assuring that election officials would still receive some cybersecurity support through the Multi-State Information Sharing and Analysis Center (MS-ISAC), which is run by the Center for Internet Security. However, she also indicated that further cuts could be on the horizon, particularly to the network of sensors that detect cyberattacks and share information with election offices.



Padilla, in a CNN interview, emphasized the importance of information sharing, especially for smaller counties with limited resources. “As a former California secretary of state, I saw how valuable it was… in protecting the integrity and security of our elections,” he said. On March 17, Padilla and 31 other senators wrote to Attorney General Pam Bondi, urging her not to shut down the FBI’s Election Threats Task Force and to explain the future of this essential resource. However, Bondi has yet to provide any comments or appoint a successor to John Keller, the former head of the task force. A person close to the task force told CNN that it would likely fade into obscurity, with little attention paid to its future.

Trump’s Push for More Control Over Elections

As the administration continues its efforts to dismantle key components of the election security infrastructure, President Trump has sought to increase his influence over election processes. On March 25, he issued an executive order that claimed to protect the integrity of elections. However, critics argued that the order was grounded in unfounded claims about widespread voter fraud and illegal voting by noncitizens. The order instructed states to provide the Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE) access to voter rolls and proposed requiring federally approved IDs for voter registration, a move that opponents argue would disenfranchise millions of eligible voters.

Additionally, Trump directed Bondi to take enforcement actions against states that accept mail-in ballots postmarked by Election Day. In response, a coalition of voting rights groups filed a lawsuit challenging the executive order in Washington, D.C., arguing that it infringed upon powers reserved for the states and Congress, potentially disenfranchising eligible voters. The suit was followed by three others, including one filed by 19 Democratic state attorneys general in Boston on April 3.

State-Level Efforts to Fill the Void

As federal support wanes, state officials are exploring ways to protect election security on their own. Fontes has proposed creating a new non-profit information-sharing center to replace the EI-ISAC. In Arizona, he is leading an initiative to set up a lab to identify threats related to artificial intelligence and elections. However, securing funding for such an initiative may prove difficult, particularly in Republican-controlled states. Even if a state-level network emerges, it remains unclear whether it will receive the same level of collaboration from federal agencies, which could be severely limited under the current administration.

Gowri Ramachandran, a director at the Brennan Center for Justice, warned that foreign actors like Russia, Iran, and China will continue attempting to interfere in future elections. Kim Wyman, the former elections security lead at CISA, explained that the agency had access to critical national security data, which it could analyze and share with state and local election offices. Without this centralized coordination, election officials are left vulnerable to growing threats.



The Future of Election Security

Election officials continue to voice concerns about the future of U.S. elections amid the dismantling of security programs. According to sources familiar with the situation at CISA, up to 1,300 more positions could be cut by the end of the month, further undermining efforts to protect election systems. Fontes expressed alarm that certain individuals in both state and federal governments may be working to completely dismantle the election security infrastructure. “I’m concerned that there are individuals in the state and federal governments who want to completely dismantle the election security infrastructure,” Fontes said, underscoring the growing uncertainty about how elections will be protected in the coming years.

Post a Comment

Previous Post Next Post